Should You Learn to Play Traditional Grip?

The Trouble With Traditional Grip

Table of Contents

What’s The Deal With That Weird Grip? 

Have you noticed that a lot of prominent players are moving away from traditional grip? Recently I’ve read interviews where Dave Weckl and Steve Smith each mention they are using matched grip more than they used to. Thomas Lang has gone so far as to say that Traditional Grip is “a curse.”

Much of what I’ve read indicates that the main issue these players have is one of power.More specifically, the awkwardness of the grip when powerful backbeats are needed can cause injury.

And I agree. This is my complaint with the grip. You simply can not gracefully get the same power on the drum kit with traditional grip.

Actually, I take that back. The only guy I see playing traditional grip with grace and real power is Virgil Donati.

But…he’s Virgil Donati! And if you don’t know him, you need to remedy that.

But anyway, the point is that traditional grip was not made for power. It can be awkward to play rock when using it.

Impossible? No. Difficult? Yes.

Why Do People Even Use Traditional Grip? 

Despite what I’ve written above, I still continue to use traditional grip in my playing because I’ve developed so much facility that way. But I understand why Lang feels the way he does. The reason the grip has continued to be used is part and parcel in the name itself. Tradition has created a lineage that gets followed despite the needs of modern playing.

And the history, which is the primary reason that traditional grip persists, does not account for the change in style of music and the greater need for power that the prevalence of rock and pop drumming requires.

So, it’s interesting to note that much of the time, when people use traditional grip, they are doing so because of tradition and history.

An Illustration of Traditional Grip

Why I Decided to Learn It

To explain this, let me tell you about how and why I made decisions on hand grips up until now. When I first started playing drums, my primary drumming role models were John Bonham, Neil Peart and Peter Criss.

They all played matched grip and so I learned by imitating. For many years I played only matched grip.

Later, I discovered the virtuosic playing of Gadd, Colaiuta, Weckl, Williams and Rich. I became obsessed with acquiring more technique. I asked myself, “If all of the greatest drummer technicians play traditional grip, shouldn’t I?”

The answer was a resounding “yes.” In fact, it was a no brainer. I did not need to know anything other than the fact that Steve Gadd, Vinnie Colaiuta, Dave Weckl, Tony Williams and Buddy Rich all primarily used that grip. No knowledgeable drummer would argue about these being among the greatest hand technicians in the history of the instrument.

The History of Traditional Grip

Now, let’s explore some more drumming history. In all likelihood, the drummers named above chose their grip preferences for the very same reasons that I did! Their drumming idols used traditional grip and they were just mimicking them. But most of their idols were jazz drummers. That has been documented in many interviews with these giants.

What makes all of this somewhat ludicrous is that the only reason traditional grip even exists—and now we’re going back even earlier in history—has to do with drummers marching in the military.

When the earliest marching snare drummers played, they created traditional grip. Like many new ideas, necessity became the mother of invention. The way the snare drum hung off of the marching drummer’s body resulted in a downward slanting playing surface. Matched grip would simply not be practical in this situation. Hence, the birth of traditional grip.

And that invention had been passed down through a long lineage of drummers, including myself and many of you, simply because a significant number of prominent drummers became incredibly good at using that grip.

So, Should I Play with Traditional Grip or Not?

Just because some big name drummers are bashing traditional grip doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t use it.

In the new millennium, a versatile drummer will sometimes require power to play appropriately for a particular genre.

So, if you are going to play a hard rock gig, my opinion would be to use matched.

But it is certainly worth checking out both grips. Some beginners have an instant affinity for traditional while some find it confusing and awkward

Personally, I’ve had a long love affair with traditional grip, and much of my technique is pretty strong using that method.

And although I used to feel that one grip should be all you need, I’ve changed my tune a bit.

There is room for both matched and traditional. Just try them both out and see what feels good to you. 

There’s nothing wrong with doing both in the long run.

Ahhh…The journey is never ending!

Food for thought.

 

Free E-Book Gives You 5 Must-Know Drum Licks.

Enter your information below to receive your free digital copy of 5 Killer Drum Licks now.

You’ll also be added to our email list which is highly regarded as the most entertaining and helpful email list in the drumming community.